DRUMS OF WAR AND THE GREEN ENERGY TRANSITION
Could this be the start of a commodities supercycle?
Could this be the start of a commodities supercycle?
By closely observing the geopolitical landscape over the past five years, I have arrived at the conclusion that we could be heading towards a potential global military conflict. It appears evident to me that China has been engaged in war preparations for the past decade, and in the last two years, other nations have also begun bolstering their defenses.
China has constructed artificial islands in the South China Sea,equipping them with military bases that serve as formidable aircraft carrier-like installations for offense and defense purposes. These strategically positioned islands act as a protective barrier, providing China with a significant advantage. Notably, Japan has also increased its defense spending in recent years, with the 2023 budget set to rise by 26% compared to the previous year. In 2021, the formation of AUKUS—an alliance between Australia, the UK, and the US—strengthened strategic defense efforts. Additionally, the Philippines has granted the US expanded access to key military bases. In Europe, defense spending has become a top priority due to the conflict in Ukraine. According to the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI), global military spending reached a record $2,240 billion in 2022.
This means that nations are actively pursuing the acquisition of vital resources essential for manufacturing missiles, munitions, warships, drones, and, notably, the microchips that serve as the intelligence behind modern smart weapon systems.
In addition to the current increase in defense spending, the push towards green energy transition is also creating a surge in demand for many metals such as cobalt, lithium, graphite, nickel and copper.
And it's not just nations that are rushing to secure supplies of critical materials. Automobile manufacturers have signed deals with mining companies to ensure they have the raw materials they need for the production of vehicles. General Motors signed a $650M deal with Lithium Americas for lithium supply. Stellantis recently announced a deal to acquire a 14.2% equity stake in McEwen Copper. Ford is investing $4.5B in an Indonesian nickel processing facility. Tesla has raw material supply agreements with Vale and BHP.
Precious metals and gold in particular have also seen an increase in demand lately. According to the World Gold Council, 2022 saw the strongest year for gold demand in over a decade. Central banks have been buying gold in record quantities. I will discuss gold in another issue but for now I turn our attention to the metals that keep our economies functioning.
For the inaugural issue of this newsletter, the focus is on commodities and more specifically on producers of critical metals. This is not a buying recommendation. I sense that the markets are going to crash either this year or in 2024, and that's when I intend to start deploying some of my capital. For now, my 2023 Fund is positioned ultra defensively. The entire portfolio is comprised of cash and cash equivalent instruments that are currently yielding an average of 4.05%. I hold GICs and money market funds. I see no need to add any positions to the portfolio at the moment.
What follows is a brief report on a company that I am adding to my watchlist. It's a company that produces copper from tailings (mine waste). It trades on the Toronto stock exchange and OTC Market.
Copper is in every home, every vehicle, solar panel, wind mill and any other device that runs on electricity. Copper is a crucial element for the green energy transition and decarbonization. The problem is that there is a huge gap between the demand and supply of copper required for this global drive towards green energy transition.
Copper demand is expected to surge in the years to come.
Amerigo Resources produces copper and molybdenum (as a by-product) from the waste material of the world’s largest underground copper mine, El Teniente. This mine is located in Chile and is owned by the Chilean state-backed Corporación Nacional del Cobre de Chile (Codelco). Amerigo processes the mining waste material at its 100% owned Minera Valle Central ("MVC") operation. From the waste material discharged by El Teniente, Amerigo recovered 64.1 million pounds of copper in 2022.
Amerigo was founded in 2003 to acquire the Chilean-based company MVC, S.A. MVC has been producing copper from waste material (tailings) since 1992. MVC is not a mining company and it is not a royalty company either. The company compares itself to a wastewater treatement plant. It processes tailings, which are the waste by-products from copper mining that contain water and leftover copper-bearing ore in a "copper factory". MVC grinds the tailings rocks into smaller pieces and then extracts the leftover copper concentrate. This copper concentrate can then be refined to produce purified copper.
MVC receives a constant flow of mine waste, processes it and extracts millions of pounds of copper from this mining waste material. The simplicity of this business enables the company tooperate without the need to spend large sums of money on exploration. Thus allowing it to return capital to shareholders when "growth capital" is not required.
In 2022 the company produced 64 million lbs of copper and 1m pound of molybdenum. It generated $168m in revenues ($199.6M in 2021). Gross profit for 2022 was $28.3M ($72M in 2021). The lower revenues in 2022 compared to the previous year were the result of lower copper prices. The company’s annual average copper price was $4.01 per pound compared to $4.25/lb in 2021.
The company ended the year with 172M shares outstanding. Cash on hand at December 31/22 was $34M. Debt stood at $24M for the year. The debt has been steadily been paid down and the company is on track to reach $0 net debt in three and a half years.
| In USD$ | 2022 | 2021 | 2020 | 2019 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sales | $168M | $199M | $126M | $119M |
| Production (lbs) | 64M | 63M | 56M | 70M |
| Gross profit | $28M | $72M | $15M | $.4M |
| Gross margin | 16.9% | 36.1% | 12.2% | 0.0% |
| Net income | $4.4M | $39M | $6M | ($9.4M) |
| Cash | $37M | $59M | $14M | $7M |
| Debt | $24M | $30M | $54M | $56M |
| Free cash flows | $25M | $57M | $16M | ($.3M) |
| Debt repayment | $7M | $24M | $9M | $12M |
| Current ratio | 1.18 | 1.42 | 0.87 | 0.65 |
| ROE | 3.68% | 28.3% | (8.3%) | 8.6% |
During the first quarter of 2023, the company produced as much copper as it did a year ago. 16.5 million pounds. In Q1 of this year, copper averaged $4.02 vs $4.64/lb last year. This resulted in lower revenue for the quarter. $52.6M vs $53.7M (Q1/2022). Net income was also lower. $9.01M vs $15.5M last year.
The company's balance sheet is relatively strong with $43.9M in cash and borrowings of $24.3M. During the quarter the company generated free cash flows of $13.8 million. It returned $5.49 million to shareholders during the quarter ($3.64M in dividends and $1.85M in share buybacks).
Molybdenum production during Q1/2023 was 0.3 million pounds (Q1/2022: 0.2 million pounds). MVC’s molybdenum price increased to $31.73/lb (Q1/2022: $18.33/lb), resulting in Q1/2023 molybdenum revenue of $8.0 million (Q1/2022: $3.4 million).
| In USD$ | Q1/2023 | Q1/2022 |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | $52.6M | $53.8M |
| Production (lbs) | 16.5M | 16.5M |
| Gross profit | $13.5M | $21.4M |
| Gross margin | 25.6% | 39.85% |
| Net income | $9.1M | $15.5M |
| Cash | $43.9M | $37.8M |
| Debt | $24.3M | $23.7M |
| Free cash flows | $13.8M | $21.1M |
| Current ratio | 1.23 | 1.18 |
| Total Cost/lb | $3.44 | $3.59 |
| Shares Outstanding | 167m | 178m |
Because Amerigo is not a mining company, it does not need to spend large sums of money in capital expenditures. This means that besides spending on annual maintenance and to fund expansion projects, the company can (and does) return a lot of its free cash flow to shareholders. Remember, this company does not need to spend money on exploration or digging copper from the ground.
The last time the company spent money on expansion projects was in 2015 and 2018. At the moment, management does not see the need for growth capital requirements. Without any large capital requirements for the foreseeable future, the company will be focusing on returning money to shareholders via regular dividends, share buybacks, performance dividends and debt repayment.
During 2022, Amerigo returned $28.0 million to shareholders (2021: $11.6 million) as follows; $15.7 million (2021: $2.8 million) through regular quarterly dividends of Cdn$0.03 per share, $12.3 million buying back 9.4 million common shares (2021: $8.8 million used to buy back 8.5 million common shares).
Remember that when investing in stocks, there are always risks to consider. Amerigo is no exception. Take water supplies for example. MVC's operations are located in a drought-prone area. The company uses water in various stages of the copper production process. The company faced drought in 2019 and through half of 2020. The company has since set in place various operational procedures to help mitigate this risk. The company collects and stores more than 4.5m cubic meters of water reserves. This reserve is sufficient to last it for at least 18 months of operations.
Another potential risk is nationalization. In April of this year, Gabriel Boric, the Chilean president announced the creation of a National Lithium Company. This proposal aims to create majority state-owned partnerships with private companies for the exploration and production of lithium. Nationalization is happening in other areas of the world. Mexico in 2022 decided to nationalize its lithium industry for example. Indonesia, the largest nickel producer recently banned the export of nickel ore. Indonesia now requires nickel to be processed domestically for export instead.
The other risk to consider is a global recession. Should a recession take place, the entire global economy could grind to a halt. In this scenario we can expect all commodities to drop in price. Since Amerigo's performance is directly tied to the price of copper, this would have a significant impact on the company's profitability, cash flows and of course share price performance.
I have a strong feeling that the markets are due for a major correction in 2023 or 2024. Because of that I am refraining from buying shares of Amerigo at the moment. For now Amerigo is being added to the watchlist. I like the fundamentals of this company. I especially like itsstrong balance sheet and direct exposure to copper. Also, the fact that this company produces copper using 100% renewable energy is a big plus in this era of ESG and decarbonization. The company produces a metal that is in high demand and in short supply. The ~7.4% dividend yield is a nice bonus. I am waiting for a 30% pullback in this stock before adding it to the portfolio. This stock traded below $1.00 as recently as September of last year. It would not surprise me to see it fall back to those levels during the next market downturn, which I have a feeling could be just around the corner.
Remember that this is not a stock recommendation. This is just something to consider. You can access the watchlist and portfolio through the link below. By clicking the link below you accept all responsibility for any potential losses that might result from buying any of the stocks mentioned in this newsletter.